Reports

NILOA undertakes research projects to examine student learning outcomes assessment at colleges and universities across the United States. Reports are organized by topic area. Click on a banner to expand the selection, read a report synopsis, view audience icons, and download the reports.

November 2018

Assessment, Accountability, and Student Learning Outcomes
at Historically Black Colleges and Universities

This report presents the background of and need for the Historically Black College and University (HBCU) Collaboration for Excellence in Educational Quality Assurance (CEEQA); the first collaborative of its kind. As both internal and external accountability mandates increase, so too has the need for a strong HBCU alliance. CEEQA seeks to help address accountability measures while being true to HBCU missions and culturally relevant assessment approaches.

October 2018

NILOA at Ten: A Retrospective

In this 10th year of NILOA, we pause to look upon our origins—where we came from and where we have been, as we look to the future of where we are going. There are still questions of the value and worth of higher education, of the learning that students achieve in their time with us, and how we go about documenting and using evidence of that learning to improve our practices and help all students succeed.

January 2018

Assessment that Matters: Trending toward Practices that Document Authentic Student Learning

Following up to its 2009 and 2014 surveys of chief academic officers, NILOA continues to provide a landscape of current approaches and practices related to assessing student learning. This report summarizes major findings and presents implications for policy and practice from a survey of 811 regionally accredited, undergraduate degree-granting institutions from throughout the U.S.

April 2015

Focused on What Matters: Assessment of Student Learning Outcomes at Minority-Serving Institutions

This report features the assessment work being done at Minority-Serving Institutions (MSIs). Comparisons are made between assessment activities at MSIs and those at Predominantly White Institutions (PWIs) as well as within different types of MSIs such as Tribal Colleges, Historically Black, Hispanic Serving, and others.

October 2015

Beyond Compliance: Making Assessment Matter

Through exploration of the relationship between assessment and compliance, the authors attempt to answer the central question of, “How can assessment work become consequential so that information about learning outcomes is used to boost student and institutional performance?” Examples of evidence of student learning accompany current environmental trends. Additionally, this issue of Change magazine features several articles relevant to student learning assessment.

March 2019

Assessment for Student Learning and the Public Good

Leaders from three organizations—Association for the Assessment of Learning in Higher Education, Association of American Colleges & Universities, and the National Institute for Learning Outcomes Assessment—discuss their commitment in engaging colleagues in productive and meaningful conversations about assessment. In this article, the authors propose 6 principles of effective assessment as institutions and individuals shift to an assessment-for-learning-improvement mindset.

January 2014

Knowing What Students Know and Can Do: The Current State of Student Learning Outcomes Assessment in US Colleges and Universities

In a follow-up to the 2009 survey of chief academic officers, NILOA again asked institutions about practices and activities related to assessing student learning. This report showcases findings regarding institutional activities, uses, drivers, and areas of continued need to advance the assessment of student learning. In addition, the report examines changes and shifts over time in institutional assessment related activities. You can also read an abridged version of the report.

June 2011

Down and In: Assessment Practices at the Program Level

In 2010, NILOA asked select department or program chairs at every accredited two- and four-year college and university in the U.S. about their assessment practices. The report informs individuals responsible for implementing assessment at the program level as to what assessment practices are being used in their disciplines at other institutions.

October 2009

More than You Think, Less than We Need: Learning Outcomes Assessment in American Higher Education

Contrary to what observers think, findings from a national study released in 2009 of chief academic officers show that gathering information about what undergraduates learn during their studies is commonplace in most US colleges and universities. However, the results are not always used and reported in ways that could improve student accomplishment and inform the public about institutional performance. Most institutions use multiple approaches to measure what happens to students during college, with accreditation being the primary driver of such assessments. You can also read an abridged version of the report.

March 2014

Institutional Assessment Practices Across
Accreditation Regions

This report was prepared for the Council of Regional Accrediting Commissions (C-RAC) based on analysis of national provost survey responses. The report examines similarities and differences in assessment practices across the seven regional accreditation bodies, comparing responses from the 2014 survey with those obtained in 2009, fleshing out changes in institutions’ assessment practices over time.

June 2018

Helping Students Develop Habits of Reflection: What We Can Learn From the NILOA Assignment Library

NILOA worked with faculty from around the country to build an online library of assignments that both foster and provide evidence of student learning. This report highlights common features between the various assignments, the value and role of reflection, and important developments that can provide synergy for further work on reflective assignments.

November 2018

Fertile Ground: The Movement to Build More Effective Assignments

Intentionally designing and using classroom assignments that align with desired student learning outcomes can better support student success, encourage curricular improvement, and inform pedagogy. NILOA authors Pat Hutchings, Natasha Jankowski, and Gianina Baker provide insights on emerging work on assignment design. 

March 2016

Designing Effective Classroom Assignments: Intellectual Work Worth Sharing

NILOA’s Assignment Library initiative is the central focus of this article. Included is a sample assignment from the University of North Dakota, an exploration of what assignments are and aim to do, how good assignments can help us gauge student learning, and how to catalyze assignment design work on campus.

November 2014

Catalyzing Assignment Design Activity on Your Campus: Lessons from NILOA’s Assignment Library Initiative

NILOA set out in the fall of 2013 to create an online “Assignment Library” of faculty-designed and peer-reviewed assignments linked to Degree Qualifications Profile (DQP) proficiencies. This report shares what is being learned through the Assignment Library initiative with models institutions can use to foster and support serious work on assignment design.

January 2017

Unpacking Relationships: Instruction and Student Outcomes

This paper explores five areas of intersection between instruction and student outcomes, arguing that what faculty do and how instruction occurs matters, and matters greatly. The intersections include transparency, pedagogical approaches, assessment, self-regulation, and alignment.

May 2016

Higher Education Quality: Why Documenting Learning Matters 

The NILOA policy statement outlines the warrant for multiple, systematic approaches to obtain evidence of authentic student achievement and addresses some well-reasoned concerns that poorly designed assessment efforts can distract from, rather than enhance, the quality of teaching and learning. The statement concludes with five principles, that when adapted appropriately to an institution’s educational purposes and programs, can spread and accelerate assessment work worthy of the promises colleges and universities make to their students, policy makers, and the public.

July 2012

Using Assessment Results:
Promising Practices of Institutions that Do It Well

To learn more about what colleges and universities are doing to use assessment data productively to inform and strengthen undergraduate education, NILOA conducted nine case studies. This report synthesizes the insights from these individual studies to discern promising practices in using information about student learning along with lessons learned and reflective questions to guide practice.

October 2010

Perspectives from Campus Leaders on the Current State of Student Learning Outcomes Assessment: NILOA Focus Group Summary 2009-2010

In October 2010, a NILOA researcher highlighted lessons from four focus group sessions with campus leaders—presidents, provosts, academic deans and directors of institutional research from a variety of two- and four-year institutions—regarding their perspectives on the state of learning assessment practices on their campuses.

May 2012

Transparency & Accountability:
An Evaluation of the VSA College Portrait Pilot

NILOA was asked by the VSA to evaluate the effectiveness of the student learning outcomes pilot project within the College Portrait. This report contains findings from the five month evaluation pulling from various data sources, concluding that while a necessary response to demands at the time, the current format of reporting needed to be modified moving forward to address user concerns.

November 2011

Making Student Learning Evidence Transparent:
The State of the Art

In November 2011, NILOA researchers released this report composed of four sections: 1) the impact of national transparency initiatives; 2) the changing landscape of transparency; 3) the display of assessment results and their subsequent use; and 4) a synthesis of the previous three sections.

June 2010

Exploring the Landscape: What Institutional Websites Reveal About Student Learning Outcomes Activities

In the Spring and Summer of 2009, NILOA examined the content of institution-wide websites (n=725) to determine the extent to which colleges and universities made information available about student learning outcomes assessment. This analysis, in conjunction with the national survey given in 2009 to chief academic officers, gives us a broader picture of the state of learning outcomes.

December 2017

Tuning Impact Study: Developing Faculty Consensus to Strengthen Student Learning

The Tuning impact study explores the intended outcomes of Tuning as well as the assumptions behind the benefits of engaging in a Tuning process. In this report, outcomes from the work of Tuning in the United States from 2009-2016 are explored. Findings address the process of reaching consensus, faculty cross-institution collaborations, implications for transfer and pathways, educational redesign and assessment, and student and employer engagement.

May 2017

Tuning: A Guide for Creating Discipline-Specific Frameworks to Foster Meaningful Change

Tuning is a faculty-driven process that provides a structured but highly flexible methodology to define the learning deemed essential to a discipline and to identify the benefits of a discipline-specific degree. This report presents observations on the different ways in which states, consortia, and disciplinary associations have used Tuning to develop discipline-specific learning frameworks.

June 2016

Degree Qualifications Profile Impact Study: Framing and Connecting Initiatives to Strengthen Student Learning

To determine the effects of the Degree Qualifications Profile (DQP) use on institutional policies and practices, NILOA conducted a study of the more than 400 (n=425) institutions that used the DQP between the 2011 release and the October 2014 revision, exploring how institutions engaged with the DQP and made associated changes in curriculum, instructional practices, and assessment activities.

June 2016

Using the Degree Qualifications Profile
to Foster Meaningful Change

NILOA has been tracking campus engagement with the Degree Qualifications Profile (DQP), identifying approaches that institutions have used to implement the framework in meaningful ways. In this report, we describe those approaches and how they have been used within and across institutions whereby the DQP served as a catalyst for comprehensive reform with the student at the center—initiating changes in curriculum and pedagogy, as well as organization and support structures.

November 2013

The Degree Qualifications Profile: What It Is and Why We Need It Now
to Foster Meaningful Change

The authors document the impact and use of Degree Qualifications Profile (DQP) on college campuses and universities. Information on various pilot projects are presented as well as the value and worth of the DQP.

Latest NILOA Report

In this report, author Verna F. Orr presents the background of and need for the Historically Black College and University (HBCU) Collaboration for Excellence in Educational Quality Assurance (CEEQA); the first collaborative of its kind.